Logo

What is the consequence of having an interested witness?

Bar Exam Prep β€Ί Wills β€Ί Execution of Wills β€Ί What is the consequence of having an interested witness?
😭 Wills β€’ Execution of Wills WILLS#003

Legal Definition

If there is an interested witness, then there is a presumption of undue influence as to the gift given to the witness. This presumption can be overcome where there are at least two other disinterested witnesses.

If the presumption is not rebutted, the interested witness receives only an amount that would not otherwise exceed their *intestate share*.

Note that being named the executor, guardian, or trustee does not render one an interested witness.

Plain English Explanation

If one of the witnesses to a will is a beneficiary of that will, then the court will assume some sort of shenanigans happened unless there are at least two additional witnesses who are not beneficiaries of the will. If there are not two disinterested witnesses, then the benefitting witness will only receive an amount of the will that doesn't exceed their intestate share.

We'll cover intestacy in other cards, but put simply: "intestacy" laws are the default rules courts follow when someone dies without a will (or, at least, without a valid will).

Hypothetical

Hypo 1: Bob lives in the state of Hypofornia. Bob writes a will and has Sam and Amy witness his signing. They understand it is his will. Amy is excited because Bob is leaving her 100% of his estate. Amy is Bob's half-sister. Under the intestacy laws of Hypofornia, half-sisters are entitled to 5% of a dead relative's estate. Result: Because Amy is an interested witness, and because there were not 2 disinterested witnesses who also signed the will, Amy's share of Bob's estate will be reduced from 100% to 5%.
Law School Boost Robot

Get Law School Boost for Free!

Law School Boost makes studying for law school and the Bar easier using our science-backed, A.I.-driven, adaptive flashcards with integrated hypos, plain English legal translations, and memorable illustrations. Start now for FREE!