Logo

What is the consent exception to the warrant requirement?

Bar Exam Prep Criminal Procedure Exclusionary Rule What is the consent exception to the warrant requirement?
🫥 Criminal Procedure • Exclusionary Rule CRIMPRO#019

Legal Definition

Police may make a warrantless search if given voluntary consent, and the police do not have to inform someone they have the right to refuse consent. Any person with apparent authority can consent, although an occupant cannot give valid consent to search where a co-occupant is present and objects.

Plain English Explanation

The whole point of getting a warrant is that it is a necessary barrier and process to ensure that we only allow the government to violate people's privacy in certain, limited circumstances. Thus, if police receive consent to perform a search, there is obviously no need to still go out and get a warrant. After all, the ultimate permission slip is granted by the property owner. So this seems simple enough, right? On exams, it can get tricky based on other factors. Most commonly, permission is sometimes given out by someone who isn't the property owner, like a guest. For example, if Bob lets Sam spend the night at his apartment and, in the middle of the night, police knock on the door and ask Sam if they can come in, if Sam says, "Sure!" and the cops come in to find Bob's crack emporium, their discovery is fair game because Sam's consent is sufficient.

This works because Sam has "apparent authority" to give consent, since he opened the door. Practically speaking, any person who appears to be an adult can provide such permission to a visitor, like a police officer. Note, however, if Bob was standing in the room and heard Sam give the officers permission to enter, he could interrupt and say, "No, you're not allowed to come in." This would effectively revoke Sam's consent and require that officers first go get a warrant in order to proceed with their search.
Law School Boost Robot

Get Law School Boost for Free!

Law School Boost makes studying for law school and the Bar easier using our science-backed, A.I.-driven, adaptive flashcards with integrated hypos, plain English legal translations, and memorable illustrations. Start now for FREE!