Logo

In assessing a claim of adverse possession, how is the "adverse or hostile" requirement satisfied?

Bar Exam Prep β€Ί Real Property β€Ί Adverse Possession β€Ί In assessing a claim of adverse possession, how is the "adverse or hostile" requirement satisfied?
πŸ˜€ Real Property β€’ Adverse Possession PROP#150

Legal Definition

The possessor must enter without the owner's permission. In a concurrent estate, a co-tenant must oust the other co-tenants or explicitly claim exclusive dominion to create adverse possession. Where a grantor conveys land but stays in possession, they are presumed to be there with permission. Similarly, where a tenant stays in possession after a lease expires, permission is presumed.

Plain English Explanation

A claim of adverse possession must be possession that is adverse to the interests of the true owner. In other words, if the true owner of a parcel of land gives you permission to be there, then you are not adversely possessing, you are a guest.

In situations where a parcel of land is owned by more than one co-tenant, the only way for a single co-tenant to claim adverse possession against the others is to explicitly kick them out and exclude them from the property.

Hypothetical

Hypo 1: Amy owns Whiteacre, a large parcel of land she rarely visits. Bob trespasses on Whiteacre one day and decides he wants to build a house. Bob sets up a fence, builds a house, and lives there for 19 years. Amy decides she misses Whiteacre and goes to visit. She immediately sees Bob's house and knocks on the door to ask what he is doing. Bob says, "I live here. This is my land." Amy says, "Actually, no, this is my land, however, I see you put a lot of effort in looking after my land, so I give you permission to stay here for the time being." Result: By giving Bob permission to be on Whiteacre, Amy has destroyed his adverse possession claim before the statutory period ended.
Law School Boost Robot

Get Law School Boost for Free!

Law School Boost makes studying for law school and the Bar easier using our science-backed, A.I.-driven, adaptive flashcards with integrated hypos, plain English legal translations, and memorable illustrations. Start now for FREE!